An Idle Woman: The Scandalous Life of Frances Vickris Dickinson

Books by Frances Elliot

Since I began this blog, several people have asked why I chose the name ‘The Idle Woman’. They note that I don’t appear to be idle very often; some wonder if it’s tongue-in-cheek. To some extent it is; but the title is in fact a homage to a lady who has been my pet project for a very long time. I’ve been researching her since I was fifteen years old and am finally coming towards the end of the project, with a book in its very early planning stages. It’s time to introduce you to the original Idle Woman: Frances Vickris Dickinson.

 I’ve given you her maiden name, because Frances married twice and adopted other names during the course of her life. She is best known as Frances Minto Elliot, the name under which she wrote a series of popular history and travel books during the second half of the 19th century. She adopted the surname ‘Elliot’ on her marriage in December 1863 to Gilbert Elliot, the Dean of Bristol (and the ‘Minto’ was a slightly fanciful addition based on her husband’s family connections with the Dukes of Minto). Her first works were a group of semi-autobiographical articles, written in the late 1840s and early 1850s under the pseudonym Florentia, through which she made a number of distinguished literary friends, including Wilkie Collins and Charles Dickens.

Foremost among her books are journals of her travels around Europe, written in a rather overblown but lively style, and these are all titled Diary of an Idle Woman in… Her diaries cover Italy, Sicily and Constantinople and offer tantalising glimpses of her network of friends and relations, whose names are often obscured by blanks (the bane of researchers). Among her other works were romantic histories of Renaissance France and Spain (the Old Court Life series) and a book on Ancient Rome (Pictures of Old Rome). You may be thinking, quite correctly, that she was hardly idle either. The same opinion was shared by the critic who reviewed Diary of an Idle Woman in Italy for The Times on Monday 6 November 1871:

On her last page Mrs Elliot modestly pleads that she has not been ‘so very idle after all,’ but the reader, who for two volumes has been wondering when the idleness vaunted on the cover was going to begin, for he has seen none of it, must still think that her truer title would have been ‘the Energetic’, or if the line must be ruled by a letter, ‘the Indefatigable woman in Italy.’

In itself, this would be enough to make a lively story. But Frances had a past that was, in many ways, even more intriguing. Her ancestors had made  their fortune as merchants and sugar plantation-owners in Jamaica and her father, who died when she was only seven, left her an heiress: an only child. She grew up among the great and good of Berkshire and yet, at eighteen, chose to marry John Edward Geils, a lieutenant in the Indian army, who was the son of a friend of her mother’s. Geils and his family lived at Dumbuck in Dunbartonshire in Scotland, in a tightly-knit social circle populated mainly by their relations. For their part, the Geils family had a strong connection with India and John Edward’s father, brothers and cousins all served their time in Madras or Bengal.

Frances’s romantic ideas about marriage faded fairly quickly. She had five miscarriages in the first two years of her marriage and, along with her illness, she found that John Edward was easily provoked to a bad temper. For his part, he must have been dismayed to find that his heiress wife had turned into a frail, demanding, argumentative creature. Over the next seven years they would have four children, but the relationship disintegrated into bitter wrangling, further damaged by John Edward’s sporadic adultery and occasional physical violence. Eventually Frances, who had moved to be with her mother in Berkshire, demanded a separation in the English courts, and in October 1845 the Geils vs Geils case began. It was later considered a key case regarding the use of cruelty as a justification for marital separation. At the time, it was reported (sometimes word for word) with prurient interest in The Times and both Frances and John Edward must have been mortified.

The separation was granted and Frances then filed for divorce in the Scottish courts – followed by an appeal to the House of Lords so that she could also be considered divorced in Britain. It was a long and painful process for both of them, worsened for Frances by the fact that her daughters remained with John Edward. After the House of Lords proclaimed her a free woman, she departed for Italy to spend a time away from the glare of publicity, taking at least one of her daughters with her. She already seems to have loved Italy and it seems that, during her stay there, she took a third husband, whose identity I’ve only recently been able to confirm thanks to a commenter here. Details of this period of her life are frustratingly vague. Her three daughters who survived into adulthood married respectively into the English gentry, the Italian nobility (the Chigi Zondadari family of Siena) and Spanish diplomatic circles (the Marquis del Moral).

 This was a woman who had remarkable spirit, dynamism and energy. There is much more, but I have given only the bare bones here, and would be very interested to hear from anyone who knows where I might be able to find other information on Frances and her family. I know there has been at least one thesis written in Italian on her travels in Sicily, and would love more details about that; I would also be interested to hear from anyone who’s studied her books (which I know appear on some American university reading lists). I’m looking for every scrap, no matter how small! I’ve already been in touch with a few descendants of her family, but if there is anyone else out there who has a link to this family, I’d be very interested to hear from you. There must be more documents and perhaps even portraits relating to Frances and her husbands and daughters, and I would dearly love to find these.

If you have genealogical links to any of these people then please drop me an email, because we might be able to help each other with our research: the Dickinsons of Farley Hill; the Dickinsons of Kingsweston; the Geils of Dumbuck, Cardross and Ardmore; the Chigi Zondadari family in Siena (between 1850 and 1950); the de Bertano family of the Marquises del Moral (around 1850); and the Pooks of Torquay in Devon (around 1900).

And, finally, what is my connection to Frances? Well, she once owned the Somerset village where I was born. As a teenager, loitering in the church during bell-ringing practice, I saw memorials to her and her daughters on the wall of the vestry, which was once the Dickinsons’ private family chapel. My father is the village historian and was able to fill in some of the answers to my questions. I initially thought of Frances as a terribly romantic figure, but as I’ve grown up I’ve come to see her as a more nuanced and even more intriguing character. Already obsessed by Italy myself, I was thrilled to think that there was a bridge between my quiet country village and all the glamour of Rome and Siena – and Frances, or ‘Mrs Elliot’, as we always called her, was that bridge. She has fascinated me ever since.

8 thoughts on “An Idle Woman: The Scandalous Life of Frances Vickris Dickinson

  1. The Idle Woman says:

    Thank you Jane, for taking the trouble to look this up! Yes, I do have a number of her books and those I don't have are almost all at the British Library. The only one lacking is The Story of Sophia. I think – and this is off the top of my head and may very well be wrong – that Lady Russell was Frances Elliot by birth, i.e. she was another member of the Elliot family whose name was also Frances, so I don't think it's the same person. But I really appreciate you checking this out – most kind.

  2. Sandra says:

    Fascinating posting about this complicated woman.

    According to my family tree software, Frances Vickris Dickinson was my 1st cousin 5 times removed. Our most recent common ancestors are Vickris Dickinson and his wife Elizabeth Marchant Dickinson of Queen Charlton, Somerset.

    There is a photograph of her on the National Portrait Gallery website. Search for her as Frances MInto Elliott at Good luck making her out in the tiny thumbnail, though!

    I'd be delighted to exchange genealogical findings with you.

    Sandra Adams

  3. The Idle Woman says:

    Hello Sandra – this sounds wonderful. I'll drop you an email soon. I know the picture on the NPG website very well – another of the negatives is at the Dickens House Museum and they very kindly arranged for it to be rephotographed in the hope that I might be able to make out more of her. Sadly that wasn't to be. You probably have a lot of detail about Vickris and his ancestors already, but I might be able to offer a couple of tidbits of interest. I'll be interested to find out more about which branch of the family you descend from – if from Vickris, then I imagine it must be via his daughter Mary and the Creswickes of Hanham Court?

    Anyway, we'll discuss by email! I'll be in touch soon. Thank you so much for leaving a comment – I'm always immensely thrilled at any prospect of learning more about this family.

  4. Sandra says:

    I'm happy to tell you that a photograph of Frances exists in an unpublished book at the Somerset Heritage Centre in Taunton.The archives reference is DD\DN/557. Title is 'History of the Dickinson Family', compiled by Major Stephen Carey Dickinson. It's typewritten, and in two volumes. Her photo is in volume 2, opposite pg 27, on the same page as a photo of Gilbert Elliot, Dean of Bristol. It calls her Mrs Elliot, so it may have been taken at the time of their wedding.The Archives have a photo-duplication service, for a fee. Their copyright rules say “personal use only”, so you would have to get special permission if you wished to publish the photo anywhere. Archives email is:

  5. The Idle Woman says:

    Sandra, thank you so much! And I must apologise as well because I know that I owe you an email in response to the information you sent me. This is fantastic news! Naturally I'm going to write to the archives straight away. 🙂 And to think that I was there back in the summer and could have called it up for myself! It's good to have an excuse to go back, though.

  6. Peter Selley says:

    Hi Leander
    You will need to spend a whole day at Somerset Heritage Centre!
    Search “Geils” on their online search
    Correspondence received by Francis Henry Dickinson, concerning the family and marital affairs of Frances Vickris Dickinson.
    Description Contains correspondence concerning her second marriage to Dr Addams and her third marriage to Dean Gilbert Elliot, and the care of and her relationship with her daughters. Comprises letters from:

    (1-2, 5-7, 10-19, 21, 30-31, 42-44, 56-58, 61, 71-73, 75, 89-90, 109-114) Frances Vickris Dickinson at London and Italy, concerning her personal affairs, 8 Mar [1861]-8 Sep 1863. Includes reference to her disappointment that Francis Dickinson refuses to see her, denials of a marriage between herself and Dr A stating that 'the marriage was a sham' and her approval by the family of 'the Dean' [Gilbert Elliot], Aug 1863 (1-2); the invalidity of her marriage, 9 Aug 1863 (5) her marriage to Dr A[ddams], stating that she 'placed myself in my resent painful position of an unacknowledged wife' for her daughter Katherine, that 'D A does not wish me to be with him as matters now are because it puts him out with his daughter' and 'now in consequence of this conduct I am most anxious the marriage be known because he evidently does not desire to live with me', 20 Oct 1861 (89).

    (3-4, 8-9, 27-29, 32-36, 38-39, 41, 48, 68-69, 77-79, 86, 92, 96, 99, 103) A J Stephens, solicitor, concerning the distress and private affairs of Frances Dickinson, 5 Oct 1861-1 Sep 1863. Includes reference to Francis Vickris Dickinson's marriage to Adams, 24 Aug 1863 (8); and that the marriage of Dr Addams and Francis Vickris Dickinson would not be recognised in England, 22 Jan 1862 (32); stating that 'she is in a scrape about the Italian marriage'

    This association has been hinted at before, but this seems to be the first time that a clandestine marriage to a Dr Addams has been confirmed.
    And who was Dr Addams? Was he Dr Jesse Addams QC, DCL who defended her in her divorce case?

  7. The Idle Woman says:

    Goodness, Peter, you have been busy!!! My parents live not all that far from the Heritage Centre so I have been slowly ploughing through their Dickinson papers, as and when I have the opportunity (which isn't that often, sadly – I spent a day there transcribing letters relating to the Geils marriage, but there is *so* much more to do!), but you are extremely good to have gone to the trouble of assembling all the references here. Thank you so very much for all your time and effort. I'd love to know the nature of your own interest in this – would you drop me an email and we can discuss further?

Comments are closed.