Grass for his Pillow: Lian Hearn

★★★

Tales of the Otori: Book II

After an unconscionable delay of more than a year, I’ve finally got round to reading the second book in this appealing Japanese historical fantasy series. While I didn’t enjoy it quite as much as the first one, this was due to the typical problems facing the middle book of a trilogy. The characters have been separated: the grand opening salvo has already been made; and I presume that Hearn has saved all the set-piece battles for the final novel. Instead, we follow the young lovers Takeo and Kaede on their diverging paths, as Kaede learns to make her way in a male-dominated world, and Takeo seeks to hone his supernatural powers under the guidance of the Tribe.

By the end of the first novel, all certainties had been stripped away; and do beware if you haven’t read it, because there will be spoilers ahead. With the death of Takeo’s adoptive father Shigeru, and the subsequent death of Shigeru’s murderer Iida, the delicate power balance crumbles into chaos. Kaede finds herself free once again and, hoping to evade any further arranged marriages, retreats to her father’s lands at Shirakawa, where she receives a welcome best described as frosty from her overbearing father. But Kaede has not spent years among courtiers in vain. With the example of strong, independent women fresh in her mind – she is the named heir of her cousin Lady Maruyama, after all – Kaede resolves not to be cowed by ignorant old men. Instead, she begins to take the reins of governance into her own hands, determined to restore the prosperity of her family’s land, but she will find it a harder battle than she expects. I found her storyline the most compelling in the book, as she struggles to assert herself and to forge her own path in a world that has little time for liberated women.

While Kaede rolls up her sleeves, Takeo has finally been tracked down by his father’s people, the Tribe, who are determined not let his rare talents escape their control. For his own part, Takeo is tantalised by the thought of learning more about his abilities, and follows a group of the Tribe across country, learning from them but also suffering their jealousy at his privileged position. Indeed, the book’s title gives us a hint that our hero won’t be lazing around comfortably in feather beds and warm baths. The ‘journey’ element is pretty standard in middle books, but I felt ever so slightly as though this one lacked a clear sense of purpose. Takeo has lost some of the honed clarity that he demonstrated in the first book and, although his sections are in first person (and Kaede’s in third), I found little to grab me this time round. He simply seems to be treading water for much of the book, until he takes a major decision which shows that he plans to make his own future. To some extent, then, his arc echoes Kaede, with both young people growing up and learning the scope (and limits) of their own strength.

However, where I had a clear, vivid sense of Kaede’s interactions with others, there’s little sense of Takeo’s interpersonal relationships. His interactions with lovers, supporters like Jo-An, or friends like Makoto, seem to skate on the surface of engagement. I didn’t feel the emotional connection that I felt sure should be there when Takeo spoke to these people. Instead he feels as if he’s going through conversations with them on autopilot, saying the right thing, but not really meaning it from the heart. He’s rather like the kind of person you meet at a party who keeps looking over your shoulder when you talk to them. It’s as if Takeo knows that he’s the main character and he’s only killing time with these secondary characters until the real story starts up again. So, from that point of view, his sections weren’t as successful for me as they could have been.

Nevertheless, I will continue to the final volume. I enjoy Hearn’s graceful world and I’m pleased that her two main characters are refusing to conform wholly to the stereotypes of ‘beautiful noble lady’ and ‘supernaturally gifted ninja’. There are points, especially in the handling of the romance, where the young-adult nature of the series shows through, but for the most part it’s an absorbing story set in an compelling semi-historical context. Now that the pieces are ranged on the board, I think things will pick up pretty quickly in the third and final volume, and I look forward to finding out how the characters succeed – or fail – in their struggle against those who hope to constrain them.

Has anyone else read this series? If so, what did you make of the rhythm of this second book compared to the first? And do you think I’m being too hard on Takeo?

Buy the book

Last in the series – Across the Nightingale Floor

5 thoughts on “Grass for his Pillow: Lian Hearn

  1. James Parker says:

    Thanks for a great review.
    I agree completely with your comments on the pacing and a lack of ‘heart’ to Takeo’s sections – it does feel a bit like he’s in a training montage whilst the rest of the plotting catches up.

    I also felt his ever increasing skill set was a problem, in terms of not feeling he was ever in any peril – and I think that’s another reason I felt a bit disconnected from him.
    However, I really enjoyed the sections that did feel like ‘echoes’ of history, with the caste-less army, and the wider manoeuvring.

    In addition to the 3rd book you mentioned I believe there are two more that fast forwards a generation to deal with some of the prophecies heard in this book – and I think that explains in part why there is so much narrative heavy lifting going on – which I think is generally done pretty skilfully.

    I read this last year just after finishing King Hereafter (thanks to your blog), and I was wondering what you thought of Makoto’s story (which reminded me of Thorfinn and Sulien). I agree with your point above that their interaction lacked some depth but I’m enjoying the way she uses these slightly conflicted third party characters to illuminate the story – it was a bit disappointing to have lost Arai, who I felt did this in the first book, having turned into a more black and white adversary in this one.

    • The Idle Woman says:

      Hello James – I’m glad it’s not just me! Yes, your ‘training montage’ analogy is spot-on, as is your comment that he seems to be so much better than everyone else that he isn’t really in any danger. Surely a full-blooded person from the Tribe should have more potential for talents? Or am I trying to be too logical about this?

      Regarding Makoto… I’m not sure yet. In some ways I agree with you that he represents a path of serenity and study that appeals very much to Takeo, but which Takeo decides not to take, and so he gives us a clearer picture of that ‘fork in the path’ moment for Takeo. On the other hand, I was a little uncomfortable at his characterisation. It felt unrealistic that, after meeting Takeo unexpectedly for the first time in months, Makoto is presently cheerfully chatting away about how he’s ‘obsessed’ with Takeo – and doubly unrealistic that Takeo would have no response to this whatsoever, other than accepting it. I feel that anyone would have some kind of deeper reaction to that confession, whether positive or negative, than just moving on and having it make no change to the situation whatsoever.

      That, in a sense, was what I was trying to get at when I accused Takeo of having cocktail-party eyes: “So, Makoto, you’ve just unburdened your heart and told me that you love me. That’s fine with me. I need a trusty sidekick I can rely on. Now I’m just going to ignore the deeper implications of your emotions while we get on with *my* story arc.” That sort of thing. It niggled. I like my characters to feel like emotionally real people. This just didn’t. And, while Makoto is *reporting* that he has felt jealousy and other negative emotions, I don’t really *see* them in his behaviour. But then, he’s a monk and has probably transcended visible expression of such things… I like your comment about Sulien. Perhaps Makoto is being lined up to act as a kind of front-line chronicler for his brilliant friend…

      And yes, I too felt that Arai suddenly lost a lot of his complexity. I rather liked him in the first book, but here he becomes a bit of a stock would-be tyrant, and that’s a bit disappointing.

      Part of my impetus for taking up this series again was that I got hold of ‘The Emperor of the Eight Islands’ recently. I know there are also some other books dealing with Shigeru – ‘Heaven’s Net Is Wide’, if I’m not mistaken. I’d like to read that, because I found Shigeru a really interesting character and I was a bit sad that we lost him so soon…

      • James Parker says:

        Yep the Shigeru prequel looks good, I think the less magic the better with this series.

        Will you be picking up James Clavell’s Shogun (or Gai-Jin) in this loose series of Nippo-phile books do you think?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s